This is a rating system designed to make the answer to the question "how fun was that?" quantifiable. You can achieve a colletive rating by doing (Gameplay * 6) + (Innovation * 3) + (Replayability * 1).
Games below 6 gameplay or 60 overall do not make the list.
10: This one of the best games ever made. If you haven't tried it, do so. Now.
9: This game is both more fun and more worth playing then whatever you're doing right now.
8: Solid game, and you should definitely try playing it once or twice.
7: If you're bored, it might be worth playing.
6: This game is "acceptable".
5-1: Somebody remind me to remove this game from my list.
0: Please send the creator of this game hate-mail. In bulk.
10: You've never seen anything like it before.
9: You could make very obscure comparisons to a few other games.
8: Big change from most other games. Probably in a good way.
7: Has some new ideas.
6: Slightly different.
5 - 3: Ehhhh.
2: Deja vu, for the entire game.
1: Start filing a copyright lawsuit.
0: It's like Pong, but with a simpler plotline.
10: This game gets better every time I play it.
9: Loses nothing in replay.
8: Only a little bit worse the second time through.
7: Definitely worth playing again.
6: Play it a few times, but that's all.
5: Twice is probably enough.
4-1: You don't want to play it again.
0: You really didn't want to play it the first time.